Assignment 11
This is the final post for My Sister's Keeper. Give me your impressions of the ending. Were you surprised? What other feelings did you have? Create a well thought out paragraph to answer the question. Then you must respond to TWO of your peers' posts.
The ending was kind of a surprise and made me slightly upset. I didn't really expect Anna to die yet, but I knew something was going to happen because I only had a few pages left to read. I'm glad that Kate ended up living, but I was still heartbroken about the event that had promised her life. Anna's death was pretty tragic, but I did like Campbell had let Anna become a donor for Kate and other recipients. It was the right choice in that situation. I'm also glad that Sarah and Brian didn't make Anna live off machines. She wouldn't have wanted her life to be like that.
ReplyDeleteI agree sometimes you just have to let your loved ones go.
DeleteI agree with the part about Brian not letting Anna living off of a machine, but I am not sure if she would want to be a donor when she was gone too. She spent her whole life being a donor, what if she didn't want to do it when she was gone?
Deleteyes i agree too sometime you have to live and let die
DeleteI was very surprised about what happened because, in the movie Kate dies not Anna. I was happy that Kate lived I was a little upset about Anna dying. What happened after she died shocked me even more, Jesse graduating from the police academy? where did that come from? And what went wrong with Sara? I was very sad that her dad became an alcoholic. I just didn't think her dad was that kind of person. But people change when people important die.. I wasn't surprised that Julia and Campbell got married I knew that was going to happen they liked each other from the start.
ReplyDeleteThe dad becoming an alcoholic surprised me too. It made me upset because he was such a nice guy.
Deleteit is disappointing that a good guy resorted to alcohol.
Deleteyeah i think that he could have found a better way to supress his sadness.
DeleteThe ending of the book was really sad and surprising. I watched the movie a long time ago with my sister and it was a lot different. In both the movie and the book I wanted to cry because either way I would not want my sister to die. I wish they both would have lived, because happy endings need to happen more. All together this was a really good book. I like that it showed different peoples points of view.
ReplyDeletei honestly though anna would get what she wanted then feel bad about kate. i figured she would end up going through with the sergery and everything would be fine. i wasnt expecting anna to die at all. i thought if any thing kate would die and anna would succeed in life.
ReplyDeleteI kind of thought Anna would end up donation too because she felt bad, but I had a feeling something bad was going to happen.
DeleteThe ending of the book was sad. When I started reading the book I thought that she is maybe getting healthy or anything but not that she has to die!
ReplyDeleteI was surprised for sure. I was not expecting her to die. In a way i was kind of sad she died instead of Kate, not to be mean or anything. I just figured that Kate would be the one to die, so i just was prepared for it. Nope! it tricked me. Anna died!!!
ReplyDeleteYeah I was pretty prepared for Kate to die too. During most of the story it sounded as if Kate was just going to quit fighting but really she ends up living! I was also sad that Anna died. I felt like she shouldn't have because she wasn't the one fighting against cancer.
Deletei was really suprised with the ending. it was different from most other books. i figured the girl that kept getting sick would eventually die. it was surprising how Anna died though. i wonder if kate is still alive now
ReplyDelete